The four men who robbed Matthew Henry in March 1713 carried away eleven shillings. They could scarcely have imagined what he would write about them afterward.
Henry had been preaching near London on Psalm 89:16, about the people who know “the joyful sound.” Then, on his way home, the thieves stopped him. His diary offers no dramatic description of the encounter. What it preserves is stranger: his thoughts afterward.
I try to picture myself in his place. I would have wanted my money back and rehearsed the encounter a dozen times, improving my own response with every retelling. Henry went looking for reasons to thank God. Four men had done him wrong, yet somehow he found mercies worth remembering without making the wrong any smaller.
People have long retold his reflections as four expressions of gratitude. He was thankful, first, that he had never been robbed before.
How many nights had he made it home safely before that one? We keep such poor accounts of mercy. A flat tire can ruin our afternoon; thousands of safe miles hardly earn a passing thought. We worry about tomorrow after spending years surrounded by gifts we scarcely noticed. One slammed door fills our memory; hundreds that opened quietly pass unnoticed.
His second gratitude was that the men took his money and left him alive.
I think of how quickly loss can swallow the landscape. One frightening diagnosis can make the sunlight on the kitchen floor seem almost offensive. A death can turn the Thanksgiving table into a map of who is missing. Perhaps you are carrying something nobody will see when you pass the potatoes. You can be thankful for life and still weep over what life has become. The Lord receives both.
Third, Henry was grateful that the thieves had not taken very much.
Here I start to squirm. Ten or eleven shillings was enough to tempt four men into sin. I have allowed smaller things to steal my peace. A bill higher than expected or the sinking feeling that everyone else has a little more security than I do. How easily possessions become our shelter. Jesus warned, “For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also” (Matthew 6:21). A stolen coin can reveal the chain around a man’s heart.
Then comes the fourth expression, the one I cannot shake…he thanked God that he had been the man robbed rather than the man committing the robbery.
Think about that. The thieves had wronged him and Henry’s diary turned toward the ruin their greed was working in their own souls. He saw something more terrible than losing money: becoming the sort of man willing to hurt another person for it. I wish concern for their souls were my first instinct. Too often I am busy proving how wrong they are. Henry’s response reminds me how much I have received from the God who had every right to judge me. Christ came to rescue sinners, including the one telling this story.
Henry still had mercies to count: his life, years of safe journeys, most of his money. Habakkuk takes us farther still.
“Although the fig tree shall not blossom, neither shall fruit be in the vines; the labour of the olive shall fail, and the fields shall yield no meat” (Habakkuk 3:17).
Imagine that harvest. Bare branches and only dust where food should be. Stalls quiet enough to hear the wind. For Habakkuk, these were the things that fed a village and kept children alive. A failed harvest meant a hungry winter. Parents would still have to put something before their children and the prophet had heard what was coming and he trembled. Then he wrote words that refuse to surrender: “Yet I will rejoice in the LORD, I will joy in the God of my salvation” (Habakkuk 3:18).
Between Henry’s shillings and Habakkuk’s empty fields lies a question for us. Gratitude begins by noticing what He has given. It grows into a trust that can worship Him even when the gifts disappear. The fields can fail. The Lord of the fields remains.
I think, too, of the people of Iran, where ordinary families want what families everywhere want: a quiet evening, enough to eat, the sound of a loved one’s key turning in the door. Christians there may face danger for following Jesus or gathering to worship. Their fears belong in our prayers, alongside our thanksgiving. Pray for civilians to be protected, for leaders to act with wisdom, for soldiers and their families, and especially for believers and churches to be strengthened and kept faithful. The Lord knows each of them.
Next Thursday your house may be filled with voices or there may be a silence you would give anything to break. Either way, you need not pretend the year has been easy. Bring the Lord your good gifts and your aching places. Name the mercies you can see. When you run out of them, remember the greater mercy that no thief and no grave can touch: Jesus Christ died for our sins and rose again. Those who belong to Him have a Savior who will never leave them.
Habakkuk trembled before he spoke of joy. If your voice trembles this Thanksgiving, you are in good company. The Lord who held him will hold you, too.
Prayer
Father, forgive us for overlooking the kindness that has carried us through ordinary days. Teach us to hold our possessions lightly and our Savior closely. Comfort those facing an empty chair, a frightening tomorrow or a sorrow. Protect the people of Iran. Give wisdom to leaders, guard civilians and soldiers, and strengthen Your churches. When our blessings are plentiful, make us generous. When our fields are bare, teach us to say with Habakkuk, “Yet I will rejoice in the LORD.” Amen.